Sparking Success: How to Build a Powerful Innovation Strategy
Unlock growth! Build a powerful innovation strategy for your business with our 6-step blueprint. Leverage AI & stay competitive.
Read more
Published
November 14, 2025
.png)
Episode
November 17, 2025
The Leadership Circle Profile: A 360° View of Your Growth Journey
Why Leadership Circles Matter for Growing Your Business
Leadership circles are small, structured peer groups (typically 5-7 leaders) that meet regularly over an extended period (usually one year) to share challenges, provide mutual coaching, and drive personal and professional growth through confidential dialogue and expert facilitation.
Key Differences Between Leadership Development Approaches:
| Traditional Training | One-on-One Coaching | Leadership Circles |
|---|---|---|
| One-time workshops | Individual sessions | Ongoing peer groups |
| Generic content | Personalized focus | Shared problem-solving |
| Limited follow-up | Private accountability | Group accountability |
| Lecture-based | Guided findy | Co-creative learning |
| No peer network | Coach-dependent | Built-in support system |
The reality is that 50-60% of your top talent may not be giving their best. Many feel disengaged, isolated, and are quietly considering their next move.
As a home services business owner, you know losing a great field supervisor or operations manager is expensive. Recruitment, onboarding, and lost productivity costs add up fast, and your competitors face the same challenges.
Leadership circles are different. They aren't forgettable workshops or superficial networking events. They are structured spaces for your leaders to solve real problems, learn from peers, and build skills to lift your business.
Companies using leadership circles have seen sales increases of up to 75% and performance improvements that place leaders in the top 5% of their organizations. These aren't just feel-good programs—they deliver measurable results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles solve a critical problem: developing your people without pulling them from the job for days, creating a culture where your best people stay and grow.
What is a Leadership Circle? Beyond Traditional Training
Let's get specific about what a leadership circle is—and what it isn't.
Your field supervisors and operations managers are good, but they hit walls. They may struggle with difficult conversations, the transition to leadership, or feel isolated in their challenges.
A leadership circle brings 5-7 leaders together to solve real problems. It's not a quick fix; groups meet monthly for one year. This extended timeline is crucial for real behavioral change.
The confidential environment is a game-changer. When leaders know their struggles are safe from office gossip, they share real issues: undermining employees, tough decisions, or leadership fears. This vulnerability is where growth begins.
Here's what sets leadership circles apart:
- Traditional training programs are often theoretical, with little follow-up to ensure concepts are applied.
- One-on-one coaching is personalized but offers only a single perspective, missing out on peer experiences.
- Mentorship programs are valuable for receiving wisdom, but it's typically a one-way street, not a collaborative problem-solving environment.
- Networking groups are for making connections, not for sharing deep leadership struggles.
Leadership circles combine the best of these approaches: the structure of training, personalization of coaching, wisdom of mentorship, and connections of networking into one ongoing experience.
The format is dialogue-based, guided by an expert facilitator, but the learning comes from the group itself. This is peer-based learning where leaders bring actual challenges to the table. For home services businesses, this model is powerful because it provides ongoing, real-world problem-solving without pulling leaders from their jobs for long seminars.
The Core Components: How Leadership Circles Drive Change
Unlike workshops that offer temporary motivation, leadership circles create lasting change through sustained engagement and real accountability.
The foundation is psychological safety—a genuine feeling that you can share challenges without judgment. When leaders feel safe to be vulnerable, they can address root issues, not just symptoms. This trust is carefully cultivated through confidential, structured dialogue.
Peer-to-Peer Coaching and Feedback
The power of circles lies in peer-to-peer coaching. Your emerging leaders don't just talk about problems; they actively help each other solve them.
From diverse perspectives, they work through challenges from multiple angles. This mutual aid builds relational intelligence and breaks through the isolation many leaders feel. As one participant said, "It's affirming being with people who are dealing with the same stuff." That shared experience provides actionable advice from people who understand what it's like to manage field teams, handle customer complaints, and hit revenue targets.
The Role of the Expert Facilitator
An expert facilitator is essential. More than a timekeeper, a trained coach brings structure and depth, guiding conversations into meaningful territory. They maintain psychological safety, challenge the group to go deeper, and ensure every voice is heard.
They are both a guide and a guardian of the process, keeping the circle focused on developmental goals. Their inspired coaching can equip your leaders to steer complex business challenges and accept personal growth they didn't think was possible.
Data-Driven Assessments in Leadership Circles
The best leadership circles don't just rely on conversation—they use data to show leaders exactly where they stand and where they need to grow.
Comprehensive 360° assessments (see 360-degree feedback) are a gold standard, backed by extensive research and data from thousands of leaders. This isn't your typical personality test. It digs deep into the underlying beliefs, habits, and thought patterns that drive leadership behavior.
These assessments measure creative competencies—like relating (how well you build trust), self-awareness (understanding your blind spots), authenticity (being values-driven), and systems awareness (seeing the big picture). They also identify reactive tendencies—defensive patterns like controlling, protecting, or complying that can hold leaders back.
The data provides a clear roadmap for development. An emerging supervisor might find a need to work on authenticity, while an operations manager might focus on relating. These insights give leaders a starting point and turn abstract development goals into concrete, actionable change within the supportive circle.
Opening Up Potential: The Benefits for Leaders and Organizations
Leadership circles aren't just a checkbox; they create genuine change for both the leader and the entire organization. We've seen this happen repeatedly in home services businesses.
When your leaders feel supported and connected, that energy spreads. The result is improved talent retention, higher employee engagement, increased productivity, and a positive organizational culture.
For the Individual Leader
The benefits for the individual leader are profound:
Personal Growth & Self-Awareness: Circles provide the space for leaders to reflect on their purpose and overcome challenges like imposter syndrome. Through peer feedback and structured assessments, they gain game-changing self-awareness.
Practical Skill Development: Leaders practice crucial skills like having difficult conversations, making strategic decisions, and resolving conflict in a safe environment before the stakes are high.
Career Advancement: Participants develop the hard skills and emotional intelligence required for senior leadership, making circles a powerful career accelerator.
Reduced Isolation & Strong Peer Network: Leading can be lonely. Circles provide a powerful sense of connection with peers who understand the pressures. These relationships often last well beyond the program, forming a trusted advisory network.
For the Organization
For your business, the impact is tangible:
Improved Talent Retention: When your best people feel invested in, they stay. The cost savings from retaining just one key leader can often justify the entire program.
Higher Employee Engagement: Engaged leaders create engaged teams. As leaders grow, their energy and improved skills cascade through the organization.
Stronger, More Resilient Teams: Leaders who create psychological safety build cohesive, adaptable teams that communicate effectively and handle challenges better.
Fostering Innovation: When leaders learn to share ideas openly, they bring that culture back to their teams, encouraging creative solutions to longstanding problems.
Measurable Business Results: This isn't just about feeling good. Companies using leadership circles have seen significant sales increases and performance improvements. Better leadership genuinely creates better business results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles are a strategic and practical way to develop people deeply without significant time off the job. It's an investment that works.
Implementing Successful Leadership Circles in Your Business
Implementing successful leadership circles requires a strategic approach, not just a conference room and coffee. Start by getting buy-in from senior leadership and participants by connecting the program to real business challenges, like high turnover or scaling pains. Articulate the "why," show the potential ROI (like sales increases of up to 75%), and set measurable goals from the start.
Tailoring Your Approach: Types of Leadership Circles
Leadership circles are not one-size-fits-all; they can be customized to your business needs. Common types include:
Emerging Leaders: For high-potential supervisors and new managers, focusing on foundational skills and building confidence.
C-Suite Executives: For senior leaders to wrestle with strategic alignment, industry challenges, and future-proofing the organization.
Women in Leadership: To provide a dedicated space for female leaders to build confidence and foster mentorship in a traditionally male-dominated field.
Industry-Specific Circles: To bring together leaders from a particular trade (e.g., HVAC or plumbing) to share best practices and solve common problems.
High-Potential Employees: For accelerated development and succession planning.
Leadership circle programs are often fully customizable in duration, content, and delivery, allowing you to target development exactly where it's needed.
Measuring Success and ROI
To prove the value of your investment, track these measurable KPIs:
Retention Rates: Track turnover among participants and their direct reports to see if you're keeping the talent you can't afford to lose.
Promotion Velocity: Note if circle members are advancing into higher roles faster than their peers.
Engagement Scores: Look for improvements in employee surveys, especially among teams led by participants.
Productivity Gains: Track concrete operational metrics, like project completion times or efficiency gains.
360° Assessment Score Improvement: Use pre- and post-program data to quantify growth in specific leadership competencies.
Business Outcomes: Monitor metrics tied to your original goals, such as customer satisfaction or sales growth.
Overcoming Common Challenges
Anticipate and address these common challenges to ensure your program's success:
Lack of Commitment: Combat this by clearly communicating the value and ensuring senior leadership champions the program.
Confidentiality Breaches: Establish crystal-clear ground rules from day one. What's shared in the circle stays in the circle.
Poor Facilitation: A skilled facilitator is crucial for guiding conversations, maintaining safety, and challenging the group.
Groupthink: A good facilitator encourages diverse opinions and challenges comfortable consensus to foster innovation, not conformity.
Ensuring Psychological Safety: This is paramount. The facilitator must actively cultivate an environment of trust and respect where vulnerability is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions about Leadership Circles
Here are answers to common questions about leadership circles.
How long is a typical leadership circle commitment?
A typical commitment is for one year, with circles meeting monthly for 2-3 hours. This long-term format is why it works. Real change requires time to apply new skills, get feedback, and ensure learning sticks. The continuous development and accountability are what transform good managers into great leaders.
Are leadership circles only for large corporations?
No. While large companies use them, the model is highly effective for small to mid-sized home service companies. In fact, they can be even more valuable for growing businesses that need to develop leaders from within, such as promoting a top technician to a supervisor role. Circles provide the support needed for these new leaders to succeed, improving team cohesion and retention. As hosts Jennifer and Chuck discuss on The Catalyst for the Trades podcast, this approach is built for the unique challenges of the home services industry.
What is the ideal group size for effective leadership circles?
The sweet spot is 5-7 participants. This size is small enough for everyone to build trust and share openly, yet large enough to provide diverse perspectives. It ensures no one gets lost in the crowd and the facilitator can provide personalized attention while fostering a powerful group dynamic. Everyone participates, contributes, and walks away with actionable feedback.
Conclusion
The trades industry is changing fast, and your leadership team is more critical than ever.
Leadership circles are a proven method for leadership development. By bringing a small group of leaders together in a confidential, supportive environment over time, you empower them to become better leaders who build a better business.
The results include sales increases of up to 75%, higher retention, and more innovative teams. Beyond the numbers, you build a culture where people feel valued and want to stay and grow.
For home services businesses, the impact is direct. Overwhelmed and isolated managers affect morale, customer service, and the bottom line.
Leadership circles give your people a place to connect and solve real-world problems. With expert facilitation and peer support, they develop the self-awareness, skills, and confidence to move your company forward.
At The Catalyst for the Trades, we're passionate about helping home service businesses like yours thrive. We believe in combining cutting-edge insights with real-world experience, and we know that operational excellence starts with people who are empowered to lead. Developing your leaders isn't just about filling roles or checking boxes—it's about building a sustainable, people-first culture that can weather any storm and seize any opportunity.
The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in leadership development. It's whether you can afford not to.
Ready to build a leadership team that's engaged, innovative, and committed to your company's long-term success? Let's talk about how leadership circles can transform your business.
Why Leadership Circles Matter for Growing Your Business
Leadership circles are small, structured peer groups (typically 5-7 leaders) that meet regularly over an extended period (usually one year) to share challenges, provide mutual coaching, and drive personal and professional growth through confidential dialogue and expert facilitation.
Key Differences Between Leadership Development Approaches:
| Traditional Training | One-on-One Coaching | Leadership Circles |
|---|---|---|
| One-time workshops | Individual sessions | Ongoing peer groups |
| Generic content | Personalized focus | Shared problem-solving |
| Limited follow-up | Private accountability | Group accountability |
| Lecture-based | Guided findy | Co-creative learning |
| No peer network | Coach-dependent | Built-in support system |
The reality is that 50-60% of your top talent may not be giving their best. Many feel disengaged, isolated, and are quietly considering their next move.
As a home services business owner, you know losing a great field supervisor or operations manager is expensive. Recruitment, onboarding, and lost productivity costs add up fast, and your competitors face the same challenges.
Leadership circles are different. They aren't forgettable workshops or superficial networking events. They are structured spaces for your leaders to solve real problems, learn from peers, and build skills to lift your business.
Companies using leadership circles have seen sales increases of up to 75% and performance improvements that place leaders in the top 5% of their organizations. These aren't just feel-good programs—they deliver measurable results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles solve a critical problem: developing your people without pulling them from the job for days, creating a culture where your best people stay and grow.
What is a Leadership Circle? Beyond Traditional Training
Let's get specific about what a leadership circle is—and what it isn't.
Your field supervisors and operations managers are good, but they hit walls. They may struggle with difficult conversations, the transition to leadership, or feel isolated in their challenges.
A leadership circle brings 5-7 leaders together to solve real problems. It's not a quick fix; groups meet monthly for one year. This extended timeline is crucial for real behavioral change.
The confidential environment is a game-changer. When leaders know their struggles are safe from office gossip, they share real issues: undermining employees, tough decisions, or leadership fears. This vulnerability is where growth begins.
Here's what sets leadership circles apart:
- Traditional training programs are often theoretical, with little follow-up to ensure concepts are applied.
- One-on-one coaching is personalized but offers only a single perspective, missing out on peer experiences.
- Mentorship programs are valuable for receiving wisdom, but it's typically a one-way street, not a collaborative problem-solving environment.
- Networking groups are for making connections, not for sharing deep leadership struggles.
Leadership circles combine the best of these approaches: the structure of training, personalization of coaching, wisdom of mentorship, and connections of networking into one ongoing experience.
The format is dialogue-based, guided by an expert facilitator, but the learning comes from the group itself. This is peer-based learning where leaders bring actual challenges to the table. For home services businesses, this model is powerful because it provides ongoing, real-world problem-solving without pulling leaders from their jobs for long seminars.
The Core Components: How Leadership Circles Drive Change
Unlike workshops that offer temporary motivation, leadership circles create lasting change through sustained engagement and real accountability.
The foundation is psychological safety—a genuine feeling that you can share challenges without judgment. When leaders feel safe to be vulnerable, they can address root issues, not just symptoms. This trust is carefully cultivated through confidential, structured dialogue.
Peer-to-Peer Coaching and Feedback
The power of circles lies in peer-to-peer coaching. Your emerging leaders don't just talk about problems; they actively help each other solve them.
From diverse perspectives, they work through challenges from multiple angles. This mutual aid builds relational intelligence and breaks through the isolation many leaders feel. As one participant said, "It's affirming being with people who are dealing with the same stuff." That shared experience provides actionable advice from people who understand what it's like to manage field teams, handle customer complaints, and hit revenue targets.
The Role of the Expert Facilitator
An expert facilitator is essential. More than a timekeeper, a trained coach brings structure and depth, guiding conversations into meaningful territory. They maintain psychological safety, challenge the group to go deeper, and ensure every voice is heard.
They are both a guide and a guardian of the process, keeping the circle focused on developmental goals. Their inspired coaching can equip your leaders to steer complex business challenges and accept personal growth they didn't think was possible.
Data-Driven Assessments in Leadership Circles
The best leadership circles don't just rely on conversation—they use data to show leaders exactly where they stand and where they need to grow.
Comprehensive 360° assessments (see 360-degree feedback) are a gold standard, backed by extensive research and data from thousands of leaders. This isn't your typical personality test. It digs deep into the underlying beliefs, habits, and thought patterns that drive leadership behavior.
These assessments measure creative competencies—like relating (how well you build trust), self-awareness (understanding your blind spots), authenticity (being values-driven), and systems awareness (seeing the big picture). They also identify reactive tendencies—defensive patterns like controlling, protecting, or complying that can hold leaders back.
The data provides a clear roadmap for development. An emerging supervisor might find a need to work on authenticity, while an operations manager might focus on relating. These insights give leaders a starting point and turn abstract development goals into concrete, actionable change within the supportive circle.
Opening Up Potential: The Benefits for Leaders and Organizations
Leadership circles aren't just a checkbox; they create genuine change for both the leader and the entire organization. We've seen this happen repeatedly in home services businesses.
When your leaders feel supported and connected, that energy spreads. The result is improved talent retention, higher employee engagement, increased productivity, and a positive organizational culture.
For the Individual Leader
The benefits for the individual leader are profound:
Personal Growth & Self-Awareness: Circles provide the space for leaders to reflect on their purpose and overcome challenges like imposter syndrome. Through peer feedback and structured assessments, they gain game-changing self-awareness.
Practical Skill Development: Leaders practice crucial skills like having difficult conversations, making strategic decisions, and resolving conflict in a safe environment before the stakes are high.
Career Advancement: Participants develop the hard skills and emotional intelligence required for senior leadership, making circles a powerful career accelerator.
Reduced Isolation & Strong Peer Network: Leading can be lonely. Circles provide a powerful sense of connection with peers who understand the pressures. These relationships often last well beyond the program, forming a trusted advisory network.
For the Organization
For your business, the impact is tangible:
Improved Talent Retention: When your best people feel invested in, they stay. The cost savings from retaining just one key leader can often justify the entire program.
Higher Employee Engagement: Engaged leaders create engaged teams. As leaders grow, their energy and improved skills cascade through the organization.
Stronger, More Resilient Teams: Leaders who create psychological safety build cohesive, adaptable teams that communicate effectively and handle challenges better.
Fostering Innovation: When leaders learn to share ideas openly, they bring that culture back to their teams, encouraging creative solutions to longstanding problems.
Measurable Business Results: This isn't just about feeling good. Companies using leadership circles have seen significant sales increases and performance improvements. Better leadership genuinely creates better business results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles are a strategic and practical way to develop people deeply without significant time off the job. It's an investment that works.
Implementing Successful Leadership Circles in Your Business
Implementing successful leadership circles requires a strategic approach, not just a conference room and coffee. Start by getting buy-in from senior leadership and participants by connecting the program to real business challenges, like high turnover or scaling pains. Articulate the "why," show the potential ROI (like sales increases of up to 75%), and set measurable goals from the start.
Tailoring Your Approach: Types of Leadership Circles
Leadership circles are not one-size-fits-all; they can be customized to your business needs. Common types include:
Emerging Leaders: For high-potential supervisors and new managers, focusing on foundational skills and building confidence.
C-Suite Executives: For senior leaders to wrestle with strategic alignment, industry challenges, and future-proofing the organization.
Women in Leadership: To provide a dedicated space for female leaders to build confidence and foster mentorship in a traditionally male-dominated field.
Industry-Specific Circles: To bring together leaders from a particular trade (e.g., HVAC or plumbing) to share best practices and solve common problems.
High-Potential Employees: For accelerated development and succession planning.
Leadership circle programs are often fully customizable in duration, content, and delivery, allowing you to target development exactly where it's needed.
Measuring Success and ROI
To prove the value of your investment, track these measurable KPIs:
Retention Rates: Track turnover among participants and their direct reports to see if you're keeping the talent you can't afford to lose.
Promotion Velocity: Note if circle members are advancing into higher roles faster than their peers.
Engagement Scores: Look for improvements in employee surveys, especially among teams led by participants.
Productivity Gains: Track concrete operational metrics, like project completion times or efficiency gains.
360° Assessment Score Improvement: Use pre- and post-program data to quantify growth in specific leadership competencies.
Business Outcomes: Monitor metrics tied to your original goals, such as customer satisfaction or sales growth.
Overcoming Common Challenges
Anticipate and address these common challenges to ensure your program's success:
Lack of Commitment: Combat this by clearly communicating the value and ensuring senior leadership champions the program.
Confidentiality Breaches: Establish crystal-clear ground rules from day one. What's shared in the circle stays in the circle.
Poor Facilitation: A skilled facilitator is crucial for guiding conversations, maintaining safety, and challenging the group.
Groupthink: A good facilitator encourages diverse opinions and challenges comfortable consensus to foster innovation, not conformity.
Ensuring Psychological Safety: This is paramount. The facilitator must actively cultivate an environment of trust and respect where vulnerability is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions about Leadership Circles
Here are answers to common questions about leadership circles.
How long is a typical leadership circle commitment?
A typical commitment is for one year, with circles meeting monthly for 2-3 hours. This long-term format is why it works. Real change requires time to apply new skills, get feedback, and ensure learning sticks. The continuous development and accountability are what transform good managers into great leaders.
Are leadership circles only for large corporations?
No. While large companies use them, the model is highly effective for small to mid-sized home service companies. In fact, they can be even more valuable for growing businesses that need to develop leaders from within, such as promoting a top technician to a supervisor role. Circles provide the support needed for these new leaders to succeed, improving team cohesion and retention. As hosts Jennifer and Chuck discuss on The Catalyst for the Trades podcast, this approach is built for the unique challenges of the home services industry.
What is the ideal group size for effective leadership circles?
The sweet spot is 5-7 participants. This size is small enough for everyone to build trust and share openly, yet large enough to provide diverse perspectives. It ensures no one gets lost in the crowd and the facilitator can provide personalized attention while fostering a powerful group dynamic. Everyone participates, contributes, and walks away with actionable feedback.
Conclusion
The trades industry is changing fast, and your leadership team is more critical than ever.
Leadership circles are a proven method for leadership development. By bringing a small group of leaders together in a confidential, supportive environment over time, you empower them to become better leaders who build a better business.
The results include sales increases of up to 75%, higher retention, and more innovative teams. Beyond the numbers, you build a culture where people feel valued and want to stay and grow.
For home services businesses, the impact is direct. Overwhelmed and isolated managers affect morale, customer service, and the bottom line.
Leadership circles give your people a place to connect and solve real-world problems. With expert facilitation and peer support, they develop the self-awareness, skills, and confidence to move your company forward.
At The Catalyst for the Trades, we're passionate about helping home service businesses like yours thrive. We believe in combining cutting-edge insights with real-world experience, and we know that operational excellence starts with people who are empowered to lead. Developing your leaders isn't just about filling roles or checking boxes—it's about building a sustainable, people-first culture that can weather any storm and seize any opportunity.
The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in leadership development. It's whether you can afford not to.
Ready to build a leadership team that's engaged, innovative, and committed to your company's long-term success? Let's talk about how leadership circles can transform your business.
Why Leadership Circles Matter for Growing Your Business
Leadership circles are small, structured peer groups (typically 5-7 leaders) that meet regularly over an extended period (usually one year) to share challenges, provide mutual coaching, and drive personal and professional growth through confidential dialogue and expert facilitation.
Key Differences Between Leadership Development Approaches:
| Traditional Training | One-on-One Coaching | Leadership Circles |
|---|---|---|
| One-time workshops | Individual sessions | Ongoing peer groups |
| Generic content | Personalized focus | Shared problem-solving |
| Limited follow-up | Private accountability | Group accountability |
| Lecture-based | Guided findy | Co-creative learning |
| No peer network | Coach-dependent | Built-in support system |
The reality is that 50-60% of your top talent may not be giving their best. Many feel disengaged, isolated, and are quietly considering their next move.
As a home services business owner, you know losing a great field supervisor or operations manager is expensive. Recruitment, onboarding, and lost productivity costs add up fast, and your competitors face the same challenges.
Leadership circles are different. They aren't forgettable workshops or superficial networking events. They are structured spaces for your leaders to solve real problems, learn from peers, and build skills to lift your business.
Companies using leadership circles have seen sales increases of up to 75% and performance improvements that place leaders in the top 5% of their organizations. These aren't just feel-good programs—they deliver measurable results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles solve a critical problem: developing your people without pulling them from the job for days, creating a culture where your best people stay and grow.
What is a Leadership Circle? Beyond Traditional Training
Let's get specific about what a leadership circle is—and what it isn't.
Your field supervisors and operations managers are good, but they hit walls. They may struggle with difficult conversations, the transition to leadership, or feel isolated in their challenges.
A leadership circle brings 5-7 leaders together to solve real problems. It's not a quick fix; groups meet monthly for one year. This extended timeline is crucial for real behavioral change.
The confidential environment is a game-changer. When leaders know their struggles are safe from office gossip, they share real issues: undermining employees, tough decisions, or leadership fears. This vulnerability is where growth begins.
Here's what sets leadership circles apart:
- Traditional training programs are often theoretical, with little follow-up to ensure concepts are applied.
- One-on-one coaching is personalized but offers only a single perspective, missing out on peer experiences.
- Mentorship programs are valuable for receiving wisdom, but it's typically a one-way street, not a collaborative problem-solving environment.
- Networking groups are for making connections, not for sharing deep leadership struggles.
Leadership circles combine the best of these approaches: the structure of training, personalization of coaching, wisdom of mentorship, and connections of networking into one ongoing experience.
The format is dialogue-based, guided by an expert facilitator, but the learning comes from the group itself. This is peer-based learning where leaders bring actual challenges to the table. For home services businesses, this model is powerful because it provides ongoing, real-world problem-solving without pulling leaders from their jobs for long seminars.
The Core Components: How Leadership Circles Drive Change
Unlike workshops that offer temporary motivation, leadership circles create lasting change through sustained engagement and real accountability.
The foundation is psychological safety—a genuine feeling that you can share challenges without judgment. When leaders feel safe to be vulnerable, they can address root issues, not just symptoms. This trust is carefully cultivated through confidential, structured dialogue.
Peer-to-Peer Coaching and Feedback
The power of circles lies in peer-to-peer coaching. Your emerging leaders don't just talk about problems; they actively help each other solve them.
From diverse perspectives, they work through challenges from multiple angles. This mutual aid builds relational intelligence and breaks through the isolation many leaders feel. As one participant said, "It's affirming being with people who are dealing with the same stuff." That shared experience provides actionable advice from people who understand what it's like to manage field teams, handle customer complaints, and hit revenue targets.
The Role of the Expert Facilitator
An expert facilitator is essential. More than a timekeeper, a trained coach brings structure and depth, guiding conversations into meaningful territory. They maintain psychological safety, challenge the group to go deeper, and ensure every voice is heard.
They are both a guide and a guardian of the process, keeping the circle focused on developmental goals. Their inspired coaching can equip your leaders to steer complex business challenges and accept personal growth they didn't think was possible.
Data-Driven Assessments in Leadership Circles
The best leadership circles don't just rely on conversation—they use data to show leaders exactly where they stand and where they need to grow.
Comprehensive 360° assessments (see 360-degree feedback) are a gold standard, backed by extensive research and data from thousands of leaders. This isn't your typical personality test. It digs deep into the underlying beliefs, habits, and thought patterns that drive leadership behavior.
These assessments measure creative competencies—like relating (how well you build trust), self-awareness (understanding your blind spots), authenticity (being values-driven), and systems awareness (seeing the big picture). They also identify reactive tendencies—defensive patterns like controlling, protecting, or complying that can hold leaders back.
The data provides a clear roadmap for development. An emerging supervisor might find a need to work on authenticity, while an operations manager might focus on relating. These insights give leaders a starting point and turn abstract development goals into concrete, actionable change within the supportive circle.
Opening Up Potential: The Benefits for Leaders and Organizations
Leadership circles aren't just a checkbox; they create genuine change for both the leader and the entire organization. We've seen this happen repeatedly in home services businesses.
When your leaders feel supported and connected, that energy spreads. The result is improved talent retention, higher employee engagement, increased productivity, and a positive organizational culture.
For the Individual Leader
The benefits for the individual leader are profound:
Personal Growth & Self-Awareness: Circles provide the space for leaders to reflect on their purpose and overcome challenges like imposter syndrome. Through peer feedback and structured assessments, they gain game-changing self-awareness.
Practical Skill Development: Leaders practice crucial skills like having difficult conversations, making strategic decisions, and resolving conflict in a safe environment before the stakes are high.
Career Advancement: Participants develop the hard skills and emotional intelligence required for senior leadership, making circles a powerful career accelerator.
Reduced Isolation & Strong Peer Network: Leading can be lonely. Circles provide a powerful sense of connection with peers who understand the pressures. These relationships often last well beyond the program, forming a trusted advisory network.
For the Organization
For your business, the impact is tangible:
Improved Talent Retention: When your best people feel invested in, they stay. The cost savings from retaining just one key leader can often justify the entire program.
Higher Employee Engagement: Engaged leaders create engaged teams. As leaders grow, their energy and improved skills cascade through the organization.
Stronger, More Resilient Teams: Leaders who create psychological safety build cohesive, adaptable teams that communicate effectively and handle challenges better.
Fostering Innovation: When leaders learn to share ideas openly, they bring that culture back to their teams, encouraging creative solutions to longstanding problems.
Measurable Business Results: This isn't just about feeling good. Companies using leadership circles have seen significant sales increases and performance improvements. Better leadership genuinely creates better business results.
For scaling home services businesses, leadership circles are a strategic and practical way to develop people deeply without significant time off the job. It's an investment that works.
Implementing Successful Leadership Circles in Your Business
Implementing successful leadership circles requires a strategic approach, not just a conference room and coffee. Start by getting buy-in from senior leadership and participants by connecting the program to real business challenges, like high turnover or scaling pains. Articulate the "why," show the potential ROI (like sales increases of up to 75%), and set measurable goals from the start.
Tailoring Your Approach: Types of Leadership Circles
Leadership circles are not one-size-fits-all; they can be customized to your business needs. Common types include:
Emerging Leaders: For high-potential supervisors and new managers, focusing on foundational skills and building confidence.
C-Suite Executives: For senior leaders to wrestle with strategic alignment, industry challenges, and future-proofing the organization.
Women in Leadership: To provide a dedicated space for female leaders to build confidence and foster mentorship in a traditionally male-dominated field.
Industry-Specific Circles: To bring together leaders from a particular trade (e.g., HVAC or plumbing) to share best practices and solve common problems.
High-Potential Employees: For accelerated development and succession planning.
Leadership circle programs are often fully customizable in duration, content, and delivery, allowing you to target development exactly where it's needed.
Measuring Success and ROI
To prove the value of your investment, track these measurable KPIs:
Retention Rates: Track turnover among participants and their direct reports to see if you're keeping the talent you can't afford to lose.
Promotion Velocity: Note if circle members are advancing into higher roles faster than their peers.
Engagement Scores: Look for improvements in employee surveys, especially among teams led by participants.
Productivity Gains: Track concrete operational metrics, like project completion times or efficiency gains.
360° Assessment Score Improvement: Use pre- and post-program data to quantify growth in specific leadership competencies.
Business Outcomes: Monitor metrics tied to your original goals, such as customer satisfaction or sales growth.
Overcoming Common Challenges
Anticipate and address these common challenges to ensure your program's success:
Lack of Commitment: Combat this by clearly communicating the value and ensuring senior leadership champions the program.
Confidentiality Breaches: Establish crystal-clear ground rules from day one. What's shared in the circle stays in the circle.
Poor Facilitation: A skilled facilitator is crucial for guiding conversations, maintaining safety, and challenging the group.
Groupthink: A good facilitator encourages diverse opinions and challenges comfortable consensus to foster innovation, not conformity.
Ensuring Psychological Safety: This is paramount. The facilitator must actively cultivate an environment of trust and respect where vulnerability is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions about Leadership Circles
Here are answers to common questions about leadership circles.
How long is a typical leadership circle commitment?
A typical commitment is for one year, with circles meeting monthly for 2-3 hours. This long-term format is why it works. Real change requires time to apply new skills, get feedback, and ensure learning sticks. The continuous development and accountability are what transform good managers into great leaders.
Are leadership circles only for large corporations?
No. While large companies use them, the model is highly effective for small to mid-sized home service companies. In fact, they can be even more valuable for growing businesses that need to develop leaders from within, such as promoting a top technician to a supervisor role. Circles provide the support needed for these new leaders to succeed, improving team cohesion and retention. As hosts Jennifer and Chuck discuss on The Catalyst for the Trades podcast, this approach is built for the unique challenges of the home services industry.
What is the ideal group size for effective leadership circles?
The sweet spot is 5-7 participants. This size is small enough for everyone to build trust and share openly, yet large enough to provide diverse perspectives. It ensures no one gets lost in the crowd and the facilitator can provide personalized attention while fostering a powerful group dynamic. Everyone participates, contributes, and walks away with actionable feedback.
Conclusion
The trades industry is changing fast, and your leadership team is more critical than ever.
Leadership circles are a proven method for leadership development. By bringing a small group of leaders together in a confidential, supportive environment over time, you empower them to become better leaders who build a better business.
The results include sales increases of up to 75%, higher retention, and more innovative teams. Beyond the numbers, you build a culture where people feel valued and want to stay and grow.
For home services businesses, the impact is direct. Overwhelmed and isolated managers affect morale, customer service, and the bottom line.
Leadership circles give your people a place to connect and solve real-world problems. With expert facilitation and peer support, they develop the self-awareness, skills, and confidence to move your company forward.
At The Catalyst for the Trades, we're passionate about helping home service businesses like yours thrive. We believe in combining cutting-edge insights with real-world experience, and we know that operational excellence starts with people who are empowered to lead. Developing your leaders isn't just about filling roles or checking boxes—it's about building a sustainable, people-first culture that can weather any storm and seize any opportunity.
The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in leadership development. It's whether you can afford not to.
Ready to build a leadership team that's engaged, innovative, and committed to your company's long-term success? Let's talk about how leadership circles can transform your business.
Listen now on Apple Podcasts
Discover how leading home‑service companies are leveraging AI, subscription models, and digital‑first strategies.
Listen now on Spotify
Learn why private equity, automation, and customer‑centric tech are reshaping the trades.
Episodes you may like
The Operational Edge: Boosting Efficiency in Your HVAC, Electrical, or Plumbing Business
Transform your hvac business operations. Learn to boost efficiency, empower your team, and grow your home service company.
Read more
Published
November 13, 2025
Passing the Torch: Mastering the Art of Succession Planning
Master succession planning for your trades business. Secure your legacy, empower your team, and future-proof your company.
Read more
Published
November 12, 2025
